Shall we perform a side-by-side comparison?

Canon Rebel with telephoto lens

Welcome to my wide new world.  Thanks to the Canon Rebel camera, we can now see vistas.  “We can see for miles and miles. . .”  We can see all the way to Canada, across Lake Superior.  (Just kidding!  The telephoto lens really can’t see that far!)

My test drive of cameras is now complete.  The decision has been made.  If you’re too impatient to wait, scroll down to the end to discover the answer to the Question of the Week:  Did she or did she not buy that Digital Single Reflex Lens camera? 

Canon Rebel: just a little autumn drive down a rolling hill last Saturday

Here is the side-by-side comparison, suggested by K O’Dell  from Banterings of a Basket Case.  Although her blog suggests she might be a bit of a basket case, I think she offered some really sage advice:  post the same picture taken with each camera – then we will compare.

So here you have it.  First two shots:  the Canon Rebel.  Telephoto views. 

Third shot:  same view from the Sony Cybershot.  No depth and makes you think the trees are all yellow, doesn’t it?

Now let's find that Sony Cybershot and take a similar photo

Next Specimen for us to analyze:  the infamous Indoor Shot.  I almost cried last Christmas when–finally–I took the Sony inside after a year of outdoor photos.  I wanted to photograph family opening gifts and toasting the New Year.  Instead…let’s just say it wasn’t pretty.

The following photo is from the Art Gallery Friday night.  Smiling cute little girl eating apple.  Taken with the Canon Rebel.  A flash button popped up automatically and lit the wee one in soft light.

Remember the cute little girl from the Art Gallery Friday night? Here she is a la Canon Rebel.

As for Ms. Cybershot, she performed dismally.  The flash photo washed out everything in a stunning bright light which obliterated the child.  This photo softened her features but makes the viewer squint eyes to see in focus.

Here she is a la Sony Cybershot who absolutely can not take an indoor photo gracefully.

The answer you’ve been waiting for:

YES!  She bought the Canon Rebel camera body yesterday for a cool $275 from a fellow named Chill. 

NO, she doesn’t have the proper lens yet.  She’s going to buy that, as well, probably through Ebay.  The lens she wants costs about $700 new, but she thinks she can purchase it for much less.  She hopes.   (Since with the new car purchase she should not be thinking about buying a lens at all!)

Lest we start imagining Ms. Canon Rebel is anything special...look who I met in the woods today!

On the other hand…let’s try to imagine the cost of the above telephoto lens.  The little lens I want probably costs next to nothing compared to this one owned by a fellow named J.P. 

It would be interesting to compare the Canon Rebel with this one, wouldn’t it?

About Kathy

I live in the middle of the woods in Michigan's Upper Peninsula. Next to Lake Superior's cold shores. I love to blog.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

20 Responses to Shall we perform a side-by-side comparison?

  1. Kathy – On a side-by-side basis, the Canon Rebel is miles and miles ahead. And if the new lens comes with the fellow names JP, please let me know ’cause I’m gonna buy one too!

  2. Reggie says:

    You bought it! You bought it! I am sooo excited for you, Kathy!!!! I’d be doing somersaults and flick-flacks down the passage if I could!!! Instead, I’ll confine myself to hopping up and down, clapping my hands and shouting with glee…

  3. kim schneider says:

    Woo-hoo. I love my Canon Rebel! I think it might be my favorite possession of all time.

  4. K Odell says:

    LOL- I’m with laurie- that fellow is sure handsome. I can see the difference with the inside shots! How awful

  5. Marianne says:

    I agree with Laurie!! I’ll buy a new lens too! (hehe)

  6. jeffstroud says:

    Kathy,

    Good for you for buying the Canon! I am glad you made a wise choice, and you have seen the difference!!! Wow, think of all the fun you will have, and you may meet more people in the woods… or not! JP must have been taking shots of birds or animals…

    Jeff

  7. Cindy Lou says:

    The Rebel shots have much better clarity and color…..good for you! Now you and the Rebel shall have many great adventures and we all get to go along for the ride! Horray!

  8. You make me want to get my Rebel out and I do have the lens! It did not come with cute JP though!

    I don’t carry it with me. Gee I might compare my Blackberry with it…..

    No comaprison for your sots.

  9. Carol says:

    As much as you use your camera, you deserve the Rebel! Good for you! Life is short, you know, and when you find something you love, you have to just go for it. Endless opportunities for gifts now – lenses, other accessories: is your Hub listening here?

    The Sony certainly did a dismal job inside didn’t it?

  10. Dawn says:

    Oh yea, we all want a lens if it comes with a JP! 🙂 What was he doing out in the woods?

    The Rebel is hands down better!!!!

    HAVE FUN!

  11. Colleen says:

    Yes…..oh, my! To all of the above 🙂

    You are going to be having SO much fun. And is it a Ms. or a Mr…. this new beauty of yours?

  12. Robin says:

    How exciting! Congratulations on your new camera! 🙂

    The difference is amazing in the side-by-side comparison. The Rebel definitely does a better job, especially indoors. Between you and Karma, I may be convinced to jump into the DSLR pool soon.

  13. bearyweather says:

    Congratulations on finding a camera you like. However, I feel the need to shout …. I LOVE MY SONY CAMERAS. I have two (one with 3 lens and the other point and shoot fancy automatic) and they are so GREAT … I have never had any problems and the only bad pictures have been due to my user errors.
    There … I feel so much better. ;0)

  14. Kathy says:

    Thank you all, thank you all. I am, however, now feeling mighty guilty about showing you only the Sony Cybershot’s faults and weaknesses. Bearyweather has made a good point. Ms. Sony Cybershot has taken some lovely lovely lovely photos over the past two years. You can scroll back and see what a good job she has done over and over again.

    I humbly admit to probably hurting her feelings by only showing the larger vistas and indoor shots which she…seemingly…cannot do as well.

    How would I like it if someone wrote a blog listing only my weaknesses?

    Sony Cybershot, I apologize. You have been a Good Friend.

    And some of your close-up work has been AMAZING.

  15. Hey, keep the old gal around for when you don’t want to carry the Rebel. She still works well.

    Besides eBay, look up the lens on KEH.com. They are very reliable and though their prices might not be as low as you’d like, they are very conservative when it comes to the condition of the lens. A lot of times their “bargain” rating is excellent or better somewhere else.

    Also, if you are in need of a lens for a short time like for a vacation or special project, renting them is a very good option. I use lensrentals.com and have never been disappointed and they are very nice people to boot.

    Have fun and, if you have any questions, don’t hesitate to ask.

    • Kathy says:

      Thanks for the info on KEH.com, Scott. I will definetely look there. Right now I am “borrowing” Barry’s all-purpose lens from his work, and a not-so-good quality telephoto lens. I think these two will suffice until a decision is made about the new lens purpose. Never knew you could rent lens! Learn something new every day. Learn something new every minutes sometimes, I swear.

  16. Karma says:

    Congrats, Kathy! Isn’t it interesting that we’ve both made that purchase since we started talking about chatting with the hubbies about a DSLR joining our lives, and we’ve both ended up with a Rebel? I had a touch of buyer’s remorse in the very beginning, but since I’ve gotten to know my Ms. Rebel much better, the remorse is looooonnnngggggg gone.

    • Kathy says:

      Well, Karma, your purchase of your Rebel was a BIG inspiration for me this past year. I figured…look at the quality of shots Karma is getting…I want that, too. My buyer’s remorse is that this Rebel doesn’t have the megapixels of the newer cameras, but…oh well…the camera literally dropped in my lap. No, didn’t literally drop. We wouldn’t want that to happen. And I am so confused half the time, where are the lens caps? Which lens to use? How do you adjust this thing anyway? Going to be a bit of a learning curve, methinks.

Although I don't reply to every comment on every blog, I do read all comments with mesmerized interest and try to return the favor by visiting YOUR blog or at least sending you heartfelt well wishes.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s